Monday, August 24, 2009

Cap and Trade Claims the Pee Dee As It's First Victim ...

Santee-Cooper Nixes Kingsburg Coal Plant ........

Following up on a post from this weekend, it became official today.... Santee-Cooper's governing board decided to delay or scrap the planned $2.2 Billion Coal Burning Plant in Southern Florence County. Though not a total surprise, especially since the board chairman let the cat ou tof the bag before the weekend, there appears to be one obvious reason for Santee-Cooper's decision - Cap and Trade.

Now, Santee-Cooper did list three main reasons: regulations (Cap & Trade), the slowing economy, and the possibility of Duke Power servicing some electric co-ops that currently use Santee-Cooper. The second and third reasons really don't make a whole lot of sense. Yes, the economy has slowed down, but usage will never permanently drop off. New power sources have to be made - be it Nuclear , water, wind , whatever - or we will NEVER be able to attract coprporations here. Losing customers to Duke Power is the same argument, except it's only 4 or 5 small co-ops, which isn't enough to drop an entire plant. In the relationship between business and government, it's pretty simple how it works... Government passes legislation, and business makes it's decisions based on that.

Now while environmentalists are cheering today, they probably don't deserve all the credit , if any. I've had plenty of experience in fighting big business from developing in the wrong spots. Remember WalMart in West Florence and RED? I was on the board. Businesses abandon developments for one of three reasons: Will of the People, Environmental Factors, or Expense. RED never had any of the three, people wanted a WalMart on the westside, the permits were a foregone conclusion, and they price was right. Even though we has another and more suitable location available, they knew they could ram it down out thoats, and they did. The same went here.

Much like the complaints against Sonia Sotomayor, this plant was designed like hundreds that are already online, so permitting would not have been a problem, as far as Will of the People, it's a no-brainer .... The majority of voters here did want the plant, probably at least 2-1, but I have no polls to back it up. That's just my gut feeling. That leaves us with one conclusion....

Lie most things is business, it was the money. Since 2006, when it was first introduced, Santee-Cooper was up against the clock. The approval process got delayed just enough for the Democrats in DC to take charge and pass Cap & Trade, making the expense just too great to build, despite having $200 million in materials just sitting there, waiting to be used. Lots of companies have had to make major decisions based on the new administration, and the changes coming with it. Wayne Huizenga had to rush to sell the Miami Dolphins because he was worried about capital gains taxes skyrocketing under Obama. This is just another business decision, but it will cost us locally a lot.

Let me give you an equivalent project to the Coal Plant in terms of size.... Picture the new Dallas Cowboys stadium being built between Pamplico and Johnsonville.....That is the same size in terms of cost. A $2.2 Billion injection of money into Lower Florence County - which has almost nothing left now, besides Nan Ya Plastics in Lake City - is almost unfathomable. Yes, there would be only a couple hundred permanent jobs at the plant, and many people would be moved into the area, but that's like saying we should close down Darlington Speedway because they onyl are open one week a year. There are plenty of jobs outside that it would create. When I was at Enterprise Rent a Car, we opened an office just on the strength of CP&L's Robinson Nuclear Plant. They need cars for trips, they need lunch, they need dry cleaners, supermarkets, gas and a place to live. Ancillary expenses, class.... In an area where unemployemnt is probably close to 20%, this plant was probably a Godsend financially.

Like they said, Santee-Cooper has delayed the plant. It is likely never going to be built, but the decision is still there - how are you going to meet you future power needs? Will a Nuclear Plant go where the Coal Plant was going to go? Where are we going from here, and does it include Lower Florence County? I can't blame them for stopping the plan. A couple days ago, I was arguing that the Health Care bill was too much. It's not their fault.... Don't blame the conservationists - that's what they are there for, and sometimes, it good they are...If you want to place blame, I'll give you three words - Cap and Trade.

.

6 comments:

mg said...

Talked to Brad Richardson today and I agree this is a bad thing for the community.

Thoroughbred 401k said...

Lower Florence County is always complaining that we always tell them what they can/can't do. They may be right this time...

Anonymous said...

If someone is serious about adding a power plant, they'd be stupid NOT to be seriously looking at nuclear. Does Francis Marion still have a health physics (read that radiation safety) degree program? Is there really a need to offer affordable power in the PeeDee basin with an eye on the economy really turning around, albeit after 2012, though that would be the time frame, IF someone got on the stick right now< that a plant could be going on line (if one is really willing to shame lefties into doing something right, inspite of themselves).

PS Mike, it really is cap and tax, the cost of teh "trade" is a tax paid to scam-meister Gore's carbon offsets scam. Who knows, ti could be a front for laundering Al Queda $$$.

Thoroughbred 401k said...

Anon, that is one hell of a run-on sentence there. I don't know what plans the have to produce additional power, but I have the feeling that the Eco groups would object to Nuclear Power...

My concern is that in the end, we will have done nothing.

Brad said...

We have nothing- that sums it best Mike. This plant to the residents of lower florence county was like the poor sick man who has been waiting on the doctor to call and say we have a matching organ. WE have to have some form of jobs in our area-- what is good for Florence is good for the county but we see very little effect in Pamplico and Johnsonvile sees less than them. It is a cap and trade shot but the enviromental people im sure is glad tonight- but at the end the people in my area, my town, and my friends and family are the ones that suffer. This plant would have been the golden ticket for our cities but its like we were turned away at the door we smelt the choclate but the only taste we had left in our mouth was -- well you can imagine. Thanks Mike for your the article well written---

In Service
Brad Richardson
Johnsonville City Council
Chair of Pee Dee Young Republicans

Anonymous said...

Good morning again-as many of the readers of Mike's blog know I have long supported this power plant. I can fully sympathize with Brad Richardson's comments,as my mother's family is from Johnsonville. What Santee-Cooper did was to snatch an estimated 1000 jobs from an economically destitute and disadvantaged area. If Santee-Cooper was truly interested in building a power plant in this area they would have had alternative plans in case the coal power plant ran into problems. As a former business owner I never put all my bets on one plan without alteratives and I can not imagine that Santee-Cooper did either.
In the end the losers are: 1)the good people of lower Florence county and the neck of Marion county to whom this would have been the economic boost they desperately needed;2)the local and county goverments that will miss out on the natural increase in revenues;3)most importantly our children and grand children who now will have to look else where for a future.
But the work does not end here;we will continue to work for a better tomorrow for future generations. Our work goes on, our hopes still live;our cause still endures and dreams of a better tomorrow will never die...teg